Buttonwood Reserve, Eleuthera
Description
An exceptional waterfront development opportunity in the heart of Eleuthera just outside of the historic settlement of Governor's Harbour. Buttonwood Reserve is being offered as approximately 40 acres with development rights to an additional 9 acres, featuring 665 feet of protected harbor frontage, direct access to a breathtaking Atlantic pink sand beach, and elevations reaching up to 40 feet. The property offers an ideal setting for a luxury residential community, condominium development, boutique resort, or mixed-use project. Currently operating as a resort with a successful rental and sales history, Buttonwood Reserve provides immediate development opportunities. Extensive infrastructure is already in place, including a resort-style pool and pool area, pickleball court, 200 solar panels with backup power, four maintenance buildings, a partial boat dock, over half a mile of roads, bridge, landscaping, signature entrance, lighting, underground electrical service, septic systems, cisterns, city water, and a fleet of golf carts, kayaks, paddleboards, and bicycles.
Where it is
What's on near Eleuthera
09/29Weekly Walking ClubDockside · Atlanta09/29Guided Workshop: Painting Flowers
Community Center09/29Tuesday Take-over: 2Minds
Muziekgieterij · Maastricht09/30Travel now through September 30, 2026.
Viva Fortuna Beach by Wyndham
Climate · Nassau
Station: NASSAU AIRPORT NEW · 12.5 km from the representative point.
Explore monthly temperature and rainfall
Typical daytime temperature
1991–2020 station normals · Average daily high (°C)
Representative-station climate context, not today’s weather or a property-level hazard assessment. Missing monthly values are not estimated.
Read the values and sample counts
| Period or area | Average daily high (°C) |
|---|---|
| Jan | 26 |
| Feb | 27 |
| Mar | 27 |
| Apr | 29 |
| May | 30 |
| Jun | 32 |
| Jul | 33 |
| Aug | 33 |
| Sep | 32 |
| Oct | 31 |
| Nov | 28 |
| Dec | 27 |
Rainfall through the year
1991–2020 station normals · Mean monthly precipitation (mm)
Representative-station climate context, not today’s weather or a property-level hazard assessment. Missing monthly values are not estimated.
Read the values and sample counts
| Period or area | Mean monthly precipitation (mm) |
|---|---|
| Jan | 71 |
| Feb | 67 |
| Mar | 73 |
| Apr | 94 |
| May | 164 |
| Jun | 253 |
| Jul | 173 |
| Aug | 222 |
| Sep | 200 |
| Oct | 172 |
| Nov | 122 |
| Dec | 58 |
What's nearby 871 places
Getting there
Something wrong on this page? Tell us · How this page is put together
Within two kilometres
| Property | Distance | Beds | Asking |
|---|---|---|---|
| 34 Acres James Cistern Eleuthera | 6 min walk | — | $1,299,000 |
| 34 Acres James Cistern Commercial Eleuthera | 6 min walk | — | $1,299,000 |
| James Cistern Eleuthera | 1.2 km | — | $75,000 |
| Oceanview Property Investment Eleuthera | 1.3 km | — | $995,000 |
Straight-line distances from the coordinates each agent published, so treat a walking time as indicative. Look at the site on Google Earth
How this one compares
6 other properties in Eleuthera advertised at within 25% of this price. Their median asking price is $4,045,500 — this one is asking 4% less. Asking prices only; nobody has paid these.
| Property | Where | Beds | Asking | vs this one |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Senza Nome, Double Bay | Eleuthera | 5 | $3,950,000 | +1% |
| Eleuthera Acreage 87 Ac | Eleuthera | — | $4,045,500 | +4% |
| Governor's Harbour | Eleuthera | — | $3,750,000 | -4% |
| Holiday House | Eleuthera | 4 | $3,700,000 | -5% |
| Unique Village | Eleuthera | 16 | $4,200,000 | +8% |
| Sand Dollar | Eleuthera | 4 | $4,300,000 | +10% |
Questions this raises
Latest to buy
